HP Smart Tank 580 vs Epson EcoTank L3252

Which Printer Is Better?

PRODUCTS

Manufacturer: HP

HP 580

SEE PRICE

HP Smart Tank 580 Wireless Colour Printer Review

Type: All-In-One Technology: Inkjet Super Tank: Yes Color: Yes Wireless: Yes Bluetooth: Yes

Manufacturer: Epson

Epson L3252

SEE PRICE

Epson EcoTank L3252 Review: A Power Printer In Budget

Type: All-In-One Technology: Inkjet Super Tank: Yes Color: Yes Wireless: Yes Bluetooth: No

Recommended in: Ink-tank printers under 15000

Our Verdict

HP Smart Tank 580 and Epson EcoTank L3252 are refillable ink-tank printers designed for low-cost printing. Epson L3252 stands out with quicker print speeds and sharper output, while HP 580 focuses on high ink capacity, smooth performance, and user-friendly controls, making both ideal for home and small office needs.

Variants

Review

HP Smart 580 (White)

See HP Smart 580 Review

Check ratings and specs.

Epson L3252 (Black)

See Epson L3252 Review

Check ratings and specs.

Check Price

HP 580

Epson L3252

SEE PRICE

Usage Comparison

8.0

HP 580 ideal for daily home printing like assignments, documents, photos, and occasional colour prints, this printer suits families well. Its refillable ink tanks keep costs low, while wireless and mobile app support add convenience. Print speeds are adequate, but lack of ADF and auto duplex may limit heavy multi-page printing.

9.0

Ideal for home use, the Epson L3252 offers affordable colour printing with refillable tanks, wireless convenience, decent document and photo quality, and low running costs for everyday homework and family printing needs.

7.0

For small offices, HP offers low running costs and reliable print quality for documents and graphics. However, modest speeds and missing features like duplex printing, Ethernet, and high-capacity trays can limit productivity under heavy workloads.

7.5

For small offices, the L3252 handles basic print, scan, and copy needs efficiently. Wireless access and high ink yield reduce costs, though modest speed and no duplex limit heavy workloads.

8.5

For students, HP delivers great value with low-cost printing for essays, reports, and colour charts. Mobile printing suits shared spaces, while modest limitations rarely affect typical academic use.

8.5

For students, the L3252 prints assignments and colour charts affordably. Low ink costs, scan and copy features, mobile Wi-Fi printing, and reliable quality make it practical for shared, budget-friendly academic use.

9.0

For monochrome printing, it delivers clear text, high page yields, and low costs. Black print speeds are efficient for daily use, though it cannot match dedicated mono laser printers.

9.0

For mainly text printing, the printer delivers sharp monochrome output at very low cost. High-yield ink tanks reduce refills, making it reliable and economical for essays, forms, and documents.

7.0

For colour printing, HP produces decent vibrancy for charts and everyday photos at low cost. However, slower speeds and basic colour accuracy limit suitability for professional or high-volume colour work.

7.0

The L3252 delivers decent colour prints for charts, projects, and casual photos at low cost. Colour speed is slower and quality isn’t professional, but it’s acceptable for everyday needs.

Performance Comparison

9.5

Printer 580 text quality — **Color Ink Needed For Black & White:** Yes

The HP Smart Tank 580 delivers sharp, professional text with reliable clarity and low costs. It prints up to 12 ppm, offers high black ink yields, and suits frequent document printing despite slower speeds than laser printers.

9.0

Epson EcoTank L3252 Review — **Color Ink Needed For Black & White:** Yes

The Epson EcoTank L3252 produces sharp, smudge-resistant text with consistent quality. High-resolution output and high-yield black ink make it reliable and economical for frequent document printing at home or office.

8.2

Printer 580 colour quality — **Max Print Resolution (DPI):** 4800 × 1200, **Borderless Printing:** Yes

The HP Smart Tank 580 delivers vibrant, detailed colour prints for everyday documents and projects. Adequate speeds, consistent tones, and high-yield ink tanks ensure affordable, reliable colour printing for frequent users.

7.0

The Epson L3252 produces natural, well-balanced colours with clear graphics and minimal banding. High ink yield keeps colour printing affordable, making it reliable for everyday school, home, and office use.

7.0

Scanner: Flatbed
ADF Capacity: N/A
Duplex Scanning: No
Max Scan Size: 216 × 297 mm (equivalent to A4 size)
Copy: Yes
Fax: No
Max Scan Resolution: 1200 DPI
Max Scan Color Depth: 24Bit

The HP Smart Tank 580’s CIS flatbed scanner offers clear 1200 dpi scans for documents and IDs. Reliable for everyday use, but manual scanning and no ADF limit batch efficiency.

6.0

Scanner: Flatbed
ADF Capacity: N/A
Duplex Scanning: No
Max Scan Size: 216 × 297 mm (equivalent to A4 size)
Copy: Yes
Fax: No
Max Scan Resolution: 1200 DPI
Max Scan Color Depth: 24Bit

The L3252’s flatbed CIS scanner delivers clear A4 document scans with decent colour accuracy and speed. Suitable for homework and office use, but not ideal for detailed or professional photo scanning.

8.2

Black Only Text Document: 12 PPM
Color Printing: 5 PPM
First Page Out Time Black: 14 s
First Page Out Time For Colour: 21 s
Duplex Printing: Manual
Input Tray Capacity: 100 pages

The HP Smart Tank 580 offers dependable speeds with up to 12 ppm mono and 5 ppm colour. Quick first-page output and Wi-Fi support make it practical for home, students, and small offices.

8.0

Black Only Text Document: 10 PPM
Color Printing: 5 PPM
First Page Out Time Black: 15 s
First Page Out Time For Colour: 23 s
Duplex Printing: Manual
Input Tray Capacity: 100 pages

The EcoTank L3252 offers moderate print speeds for home and small offices. Draft mode is fast, standard printing slower, and photo printing gradual, making it suitable for light to moderate workloads.

8.7

Black Cartridge Price: ₹723
Color Cartridge Price: ₹711 per bottle x 3 = ₹2,133
Black-Only Printing Cost: ₹0.12
Color Printing Cost: ₹0.33
Draft Black Printing Cost: ₹₹0.08–₹0.10
Draft Colour Printing Cost: ₹0.25–₹0.30

The HP Smart Tank 580 offers very low printing costs with high ink yields. Black prints cost about ₹0.12 per page, colour around ₹0.33, with draft mode reducing expenses further for economical, high-volume use.

8.7

Black Cartridge Price: ₹795
Color Cartridge Price: ₹795 per bottle x 3 = ₹2,385
Black-Only Printing Cost: ₹0.10
Color Printing Cost: ₹0.35
Draft Black Printing Cost: ₹₹0.07–₹0.09
Draft Colour Printing Cost: ₹0.15

The Epson EcoTank L3252 offers very low running costs, making it ideal for home, students, and small offices. It saves money on black, colour, and occasional image printing long term.

Design Comparison

8.5

Type: All-in-one
Height: 157.26 mm
Width: 434.66 mm
Depth: 361.53 mm
Weight: 5.03 kg

The HP Smart Tank 580 features a compact, professional design with a matte-black finish. Solid build quality, transparent front ink tanks, and a foldable tray make it practical for home and small offices.

9.0

Type: All-in-one
Height: 179 mm
Width: 375 mm
Depth: 347 mm
Weight: 3.9 kg

The Epson L3252 has a compact, modern design suited for small spaces. Its lightweight plastic body feels practical and sturdy enough for regular home or small-office printing, though not premium.

6.5

Display Screen: Yes
Display Screen Size: 1.2 inches
Touchscreen: No

0.0

There is no display screen — instead, the printer has a simple control panel with physical buttons, which keeps the interface straightforward and low-maintenance.

Since there’s no display screen, users won’t be navigating complex menus, which is ideal for a workhorse printer focused on economy and reliability.

9.0

SuperTank: Yes
Photo Cartridge: No
Colour: Yes
Number Of Color Cartridges: 3
Black Cartridge Model: HP GT53
Tested Black Page Yield: 297
Estimated Black Page Yield: 6271 Prints
Color Cartridge Model: HP GT52 C/M/Y
Tested Color Page Yield: 170 Prints
Estimated Color Page Yield: 3866 Prints
Ink Type: Dye And Pigment
High Yield Cartridge: Yes

The HP Smart Tank 580 All-in-One offers impressive cost efficiency for black-and-white printing. Considering its yield and clarity, the HP Smart Tank 580 provides an excellent balance between affordability and quality for both text and graphics printing.

9.5

SuperTank: Yes
Photo Cartridge: No
Colour: Yes
Number Of Color Cartridges: 3
Black Cartridge Model: EP-003
Tested Black Page Yield: 324
Estimated Black Page Yield: 6520 Prints
Color Cartridge Model: EP-003 C/M/Y
Tested Color Page Yield: 200 Prints
Estimated Color Page Yield: 4000 Prints
Ink Type: Dye And Pigment
High Yield Cartridge: Yes

The Epson L3252 ink bottles offer slightly higher print yields than the HP 580, though the difference isn’t large. Print clarity is comparable, delivering a strong balance of affordability and quality for both text and graphics.

8.2

Ink Related Maintenance: Expected
Drum Unit: No

What is Ink related maintenance: Whether the printer requires any ink-related maintenance beyond simply replacing cartridges.

When it’s important: If you prefer to avoid occasional print head cleaning or replacing ink pads.

8.0

Ink Related Maintenance: Expected
Drum Unit: No

What is Drum Unit refers to: The placement of the drum unit inside the laser printer.

When it’s important: If the drum unit is separate, it will eventually need replacement, adding cost and maintenance. When it’s included with the toner cartridge, replacement is simpler and hassle-free.

4.0

Print Technology: Inkjet

4.0

Print Technology: Inkjet

The Epson L3252 is extremely economical, offering very low per-page costs with its EcoTank system. Affordable, high-yield ink bottles make it ideal for frequent, long-term printing at minimal expense.